Tract #57: Should Atheists Disrespect Religion?

Tract #57, Should Atheists Disrespect Religion?, is ready for you to print and hand out. Download it, see page #3 for printing instructions, and let me know your comments! Thanks!

057_respect-religion.pdf


Should Atheists Disrespect Religion?

Is there any reason for an atheist to respect people’s religious beliefs and practices? Or is it “open season” on the ridiculous things religious people think and do?

For example, some atheists actively disrespect religious practices by making a show of not waiting for grace to be said before eating a meal with religious relatives. But what is the point of such disrespect?

If this is intended as a demonstration of atheism or to show that the atheist thinks religion is “stupid,” then the performance is likely less than effective. People may remember the atheist’s behavior as rudeness or condescension and conclude that such behavior goes along with a lack of religious belief. Alternately, they may simply think the atheist is a jerk.

If the disruptive behavior is intended to make it difficult for people to practice their beliefs, then the atheist is inviting payback in kind. In fact, no matter how you slice it, this kind of behavior is problematic from a philosophical standpoint.

If the atheist is striking out at religion because religious behavior feels like an attack on atheism, then odds aren’t bad that the atheist is not really mad at religion, but rather mad about how religious people are treating him.

Some atheists think that there’s nothing wrong with disrupting or disrespecting religious things because religion is false and therefore has no value. But even if these things mean nothing to an atheist, they do have value to religious people. And if you disrespect things that others consider valuable, you can’t demand that they respect things that you consider valuable.

For example, consider an atheist teenager who, forced to go to church with her parents, makes loud snoring noises during a moment of what is supposed to be silent prayer, or who grinningly hands out ham sandwiches at a family picnic that is supposed to be kosher. In both of these cases, she thinks she’s not really doing anything wrong since religion is false so talking to God or keeping kosher mean nothing.

Would this same teenager be upset if her little brother got a permanent marker and drew dinosaurs on the teddy bear she’d had since she was two? At worst, he’s damaged a raggedy old toy that wouldn’t fetch $1 at a garage sale, so there’s no reason for her to care, right?

Would she be upset if her band got to play at a school dance and a bunch of kids threw water balloons at them? The band wasn’t being paid so they didn’t lose anything, and the water-balloon assault was more entertaining than the band’s music (which, the balloon throwers assure her, stunk). So where’s the harm?

The fact is, we all have things, practices, or traditions that we value but that others don’t care about. So long as these things don’t hurt anyone, the moral atheist doesn’t attack them. There’s no reason to, and many reasons not to.

Posted on November 27, 2009 at 10:11 pm by ideclare · Permalink
In: Dealing with religious folks, Tract

One Response

Subscribe to comments via RSS

  1. Written by Dan
    on December 24, 2009 at 1:31 pm
    Reply · Permalink

    There are many reasons one could list for not respecting religion. Indeed no belief, be it religious, political, or philosophical in nature should receive automatic respect or be free from criticism or attack. If one is a Deontologist, then that viewpoint is just as open to criticism and attack as the belief that invisible goblins are responsible for tripping people, or that a crucified martyr zombie wants you to eat his flesh and drink his blood (though some ideas are more ridiculous than others, and thus easier to criticize). Criticism and active demonstrations against religion or *any* idea, even though it may cause disrespect or offense, can be an effective influence–contrary to what this ‘tract’ seems inclined to persuade us to think (“People may remember the atheist’s behavior as rudeness or condescension…”, “…they may simply think the atheist is a jerk.” et cetera. Sorry, but I disagree. A lot of other people do as well, and there are plenty of blog posts/books/websites/etc. one can read that expound on the points I won’t make here about the benefits of not respecting religion. To be fair, even though I disagree with this ‘tract,’ I really appreciate what you guys are doing here. I Stumbled (StumbleUpon) onto the website homepage, which is very amusing (I wonder how many religious people you’ve pissed off with that). Keep it up guys!

Subscribe to comments via RSS

Leave a Reply