Archive for the Criticism Category
Published October 9th, 2008
I don’t understand why we are all so naive and confident as to assume that we must and do know everything right here, right now. You all have nice long rants about “Why we are” and “Scientists cannot replicate”: How “evolution fails” and “right from wrong”. Does anyone else (except myself, obviously) believe that we [...]
Published March 27th, 2008
As an agnostic, I find your site to be in bad taste and to be offensive.
That’s pretty harsh. Can you be more specific?
Published March 20th, 2008
I appreciate your site. As a fellow atheist, I’m always glad to see people banding together in the name of reason. But I’m a little worried at the sarcastic nature of the site. For now at least, I feel that we should be using logic and reasoning to dissolve the idea of god instead of [...]
Published March 10th, 2008
I don’t think many of your rights and responsibilities for atheists are reasonable.
Well, they’re not meant to be taken seriously, but I’d be interested to know which ones you don’t find reasonable.
Published December 27th, 2007
As an Atheist, I found the “Argument Against” section to be rather childish and a tad bit intellectually insulting. Maybe I missed the point, and the purpose of the site is all about sarcastic humor, but even then it would still be pretty much without merit. While reading the mentioned section, I pictured someone actually [...]
Published December 27th, 2007
I am an Australian Aborigine. I think if athiest means non-Christian or non any organized religion, then fine. Go for it. But please don’t denigrate God if you do not understand what spirituality is. The scientists, who have been pushing the philosophy of the power of individual logic and reason, got it wrong too. At [...]
Published November 16th, 2007
An honest question: how can you be so sure?
(Also, a pet peeve- your rights and responsibilities page. I didn’t get the memo that not believing in a god signed me up for a whole new other club. It’s a personal choice, belief, whatever; it’s not a church without a centre and it hasn’t got a [...]
Published September 12th, 2007
I noticed in your atheist rights and responsibilities, you list “Don’t be greedy”. I would argue that being greedy is not morally incorrect. In fact, I would argue that greed is a natural and society improving human process.
Laissez-faire capitalism is a system in which individuals produce goods and services that they trade with one another [...]
Published September 5th, 2007
Even though I’m an atheist, i find the IAmAnAtheist.com website a bit offensive. I mean, no one should have the right to say to anyone whether or not he/she is an atheist, or a christian, or a pastafarian. I know it’s supposed to be funny but still, it struck a minor chord (ha ha [...]
Published September 4th, 2007
I “stumbled” into this page using stumbleupon and was rather amused by the contents despite my Christian beliefs. I appreciate your attempt to knock down Christianity as far as possible, but would like to request that you understand it before commenting upon it. Christianity IS inherently exclusive – nobody is going to argue that [...]
« Previous Entries